Last updated: February 11, 2025

BGSU seal

Classics Program at BGSU
Studies in Latin at BGSU
Department of World Languages and Cultures
Instagram: bgsu_languages
Twitter: BGSU_Languages
Facebook: BGSU Languages
Bowling Green State University


 a knight in plate armor blowing a horn while riding a
            hippogriff;
  Fabrizio Baldo, Astolfo rides the hippogriff
(illustration for Orlando Furioso)


CLCV 3880/3880H-1001: Medieval Legend

(a.k.a. "Wizards, Warriors, and Witches")

Tuesday/Thursday 2:30-3:45
Eppler South 307

Professor:
James M. Pfundstein, Ph.D.
Shatzel 222
Office Hours:12:30-1:20 Tuesday, and by appointment
Office phone: 419-372-8278
e-mail: jmpfund@bgsu.edu
web-page: https://blogs.bgsu.edu/pfundblog/syllabi/
facebook: james.enge
bluesky: jamesenge

Required Texts
:


    links to Amazon (which is not an endorsement; you can get these texts elsewhere)

    or Archive.org (which is an endorsement, although you can still get these texts elsewhere):
The Matter of Britain:
Geoffrey of Monmouth, Historia Regum Brittaniae (selections)
PDF available here (and elsewhere online):
https://archive.org/details/britishhistoryg01geofgoog/page/n6/mode/2up

Guest, Charlotte (transl.) Mabinogion (selections: “The Lady of the Fountain”; “Peredur, Son of Evrawc”)
PDF available here (and elsewhere online)
https://archive.org/details/mabinogion01schr
Weston, Jessie (transl.) Sir Gawaine and the Green Knight (1897)
original edition here (free, but in a rather soupy, marked-up PDF)
https://archive.org/details/sirgawaingreenkn00west
reprint edition here (not free, but you can get a clean hardcopy)
https://www.amazon.com/Gawain-Green-Knight-Dover-Literature/dp/0486431916/
Malory, Morte d’Arthur (selections)
in various formats at Project Gutenberg
volume 1: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/1251

volume 2: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/1252
as a single PDF at Archive.org:
https://archive.org/details/lemortedarthursi00malorich

Matarosso, Pauline The Quest of the Holy Grail (Penguin, 1969)


Cable, The Death of King Arthur (Penguin, 1972)

The Matter of Rome

Hunt's modernized version of the Middle English romance, Sir Orfeo is available at archive.org.

Richard Scott-Robinson's modernized version of Octavian is online here.

The Matter of France

Sayers, Dorothy (transl.) The Song of Roland (Penguin, 1957)
used copies available here
also online for free at archive.org here: https://archive.org/details/thesongofroland
Reynolds, Barbara (transl.) Ariosto: Orlando Furioso Pt. 1 & Pt. 2 (Penguin, 1975/1977)

Online Resources:
What is standard manuscript formatting? For the purposes of this class, see the link below.
https://jamesenge.com/GenericMythArgument.wordformat.pdf
The T.E.A.M.S. Middle English texts series has an extremely rich website, including texts in Middle English, and jumping-off points for research, including the Robin Hood Project and (more relevant for our topic) the Camelot Project.
https://d.lib.rochester.edu/teams

Bouchier (et al.), Huon of Bordeaux (Ruskin, 1985)
https://archive.org/details/huonofbordeauxdo00bernuoft

The Labyrinth at Georgetown University's website is a repository for studies of medieval Europe in general, and has a section of Arthuriana. 
https://blogs.commons.georgetown.edu/labyrinth/
Alternate versions of Sir Orfeo: Tolkien's is also online, but I'm dubious about whether the site has the right to post it. Another modernized version, by Richard Scott-Robinson, is here.

Weston's Gawain at the Grail Castle (1903) is online at The Internet Archive and elsewhere.
https://archive.org/details/SirGawainAtTheGrailCastle1903/page/n7/mode/2up
etc!

If you find any other good sources, let me know. I'll be expanding this section as more stuff comes to my attention.


Course Expectations:

1. Expectations for Behavior: Abide by Wheaton's Law. For details, see the BGSU Codes of Conduct.

2. Expectations for Learning: This is a survey course in medieval legends, and will involve readings in translation from a variety of sources (Latin, Welsh, Old French, Middle English). By the end of it you should have a good sense of what myth is (as opposed to, say, religion), and what medieval legend is in particular; you will have had a chance to read and write and think about these myths and their applicability to our culture and our time.

Survey courses are, of necessity, somewhat heterogeneous. This means that I'll be covering a lot of topics which may not obviously be related to each other, and also I will use a lot of words like "heterogeneous". You might think of the myths as the members of an extended family. They're not all the same, and none of them are exactly the same. But there is an undeniable organic relation between them, and the more of them you know the more you will see the resemblance.

3. About COVID-19 and masking protocols:

Here’s the deal. COVID-19 is a highly communicable and potentially deadly disease, and it's still around. I'm taking the risk of not using a mask in class, for the sake of clarity in my lectures, but if you want to use a mask in class, I urge you to do so. I would certainly do so if I were taking this class rather than lecturing in it.

4. AI Use Guidelines

Don't use generative AI (i.e. chatbots) for the assignments in this class. Setting aside the fact that chatbots routinely violate intellectual property law and are ethically and environmentally unsustainable, the technology does not work as advertised. It cannot cite required sources accurately, for instance (unless it happens to be plagiarizing a source that does). These programs don't create writing based on knowledge; they generate text using statistical probabilities and a very large database, a process that has been described as "stochastic parroting". If you've ever seen a weird autocomplete on your phone, be aware that this is what AI does routinely. It's instantly obvious to anyone who reads carefully, which is one of the things you're paying me to do.

"Aha, Pfundstein!" you may say in the silent precincts of your heart, "how will you know, know for a fact that I used AI? If not, how can you ban it?"

I don’t ban it (except insofar as it’s already banned under the intellectual honesty section of the BGSU code of conduct). But I grade for elements that generative AI can’t provide (e.g. accurate and relevant citations of specific evidence)—not to exclude text generated by chatbots, but because the ability to do that stuff is a sign of actual intelligence (which, despite the name on the label, AI doesn’t have). You could generate a first draft for your paper using a chatbot, then laboriously go in and add references from the required texts. But, of course, to be useful, the references are going to have to be relevant to the argument. You could then rewrite the essay to make it more relevant to the required texts. But, if you’re looking for the quickest and easiest path to success, you might find that it’s just easier to write the damn thing yourself.

"So what do I write about?" is a question I hear a lot, and it’s a reasonable question, especially if you haven’t had a course like this before. Step one is to read the stuff. If you read the texts, you’ll find something interesting or irritating enough to say something about; just say it in print, rather than out loud. I also include topics and questions alongside the reading schedule that may jog something.

Assignments:
(see schedule below for due dates)
Arguments are 500-word essays based on the readings, lecture notes, and discussions as listed in the schedule. They should include a brief thesis statement ("Medieval legends are really about potatoes!"), defended by an argument ("Because potatoes are the only thing that appear in every one of the myths that we saw in this section!") supported by evidence ("[Potato-Legend 1], [Potato-Legend 2], [Potato-Legend 3]," etc.) documented by precise citations.

Cite the source of anything you quote or paraphrase, and always cite as specifically as possible. For a modern book (like Matarosso's) this means page numbers. For Roland this means stanza numbers; for Orlando Furioso it means canto and stanza numbers; etc. Don't cite sources other than the required readings unless you have some very strong reason for doing so: I want you to show me that you know the assigned material, not that you know how to google something. Do make copious use of the assigned readings. If you've finished the assignment without mentioning the assigned readings, go back in and include citations from these sources.

Use standard manuscript formatting for the arguments and the final project.

You'll submit the arguments online through the assignment page on Canvas. (Don't email them to me or send me hardcopies.)

 

Quizzes are strictly objective (true/false, matching, short ID, visual ID, etc) based on the readings, slideshows, and lecture notes. They'll be administered in class.

The Final Project  is a 1000-word paper (submitted via Canvas), which could be a longer version of the argument-style essay, or some other writing project as negotiated with the instructor. But similar standards (e.g. intensive use of the required materials, use of standard MS. format, etc.) apply.


Grading
:
 

2 arguments

4 quizzes


1 final project

 
30%

40%

30%


 
THE FINE PRINT:
 No makeups given due to absence without prior arrangement with the instructor.
 No one can pass the course without passing the final quiz and turning in the final project.
 Incompletes will only be issued for pressing reasons and by prior arrangement with the instructor.
"Destiny leads the willing, and drags the unwilling."--Seneca
 The instructor reserves the right to recognize significant improvement (or decline) in student performance when awarding the final grade.
 The maximum amount of extra credit which may count towards the final grade = 5% of the total course points.
 The syllabus is subject to change at the discretion of the instructor; changes will be announced via Canvas and posted on-line.


SCHEDULE

week readings assignments topics & arguments
Week 1:
 January 14, 16
Geoffrey of Monmouth (selections)

Merlin’s origin story and Vortigern’s death (Book VI chs. XVII-XIX, Book VIII, chs. I-II).

Merlin & Stonehenge (Book VIII, chs. X-XII)


History, Myth, and Legend


What's the Matter with Romance?
(This super-funny joke will require
an hour or so of tedious explanation.)

 

Romans, Britons, Anglo-Saxons, and other imaginary beings

The historical Arthur (and Merlin?) and Charlemagne


The Matter of Britain

Week 2:
January 21, 23

Geoffrey of Monmouth (selections)


Uther & Arthur (Book VIII, chs. XV, XVII, XIX, XXII, XXIV)

Death (?) of Arthur (Book XI, chs. I-II)


Arthur the hero

The Raglan Scale

Merlin's magic: fantasy or science fiction?

Week 3:
January 28, 30

Guest's translation of The Mabinogion:

“The Lady of the Fountain”,

“Peredur, Son of Evrawc”

Thursday
January 30: 
Quiz 1 

(readings & lectures
weeks 1-3)


The fool and the hero

 

Arthur the non-hero,
or: Can a king be a hero?

 

The British knights of the Round Table

Week 4:
February 4, 6

Weston's version of
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight


The chivalric code

 

pagan and Christian elements the story

 

The traitor Aeneas vs. the faithful Gawaine

 

fantasy or allegory or...?

Week 5:
February 11, 13

Malory, Morte d’Arthur

Book 1: The Coming of Arthur;

Book 11: Adventures of Lancelot

Friday February 14, 11:59 PM:
Argument 1

(readings & lectures
weeks 1-5)


Merlin the Trickster

 

Arthur and Hercules


Sex, deceit, and violence in French romance

 

The French Knights of the Round Table


The monstrification of British knights in French romances

Week 6:
February 18, 20
Matarosso's translation of The Quest of the Holy Grail


Biblical legend and Britain

 

The True Cross and Britain

 

Holiness and chivalry: contradictory ideals?

 

holiness vs. magic; holiness as magic

Week 7:
February 25, 27
Cable's translation of The Death of King Arthur Thursday February 27:
Quiz 2 


(readings & lectures
weeks 4-8)


Mordred: villain or hero?

 

Lancelot: villain or hero?

 

After Avalon: the afterlife of Arthur


Spring Break: March 1-9
no classes


Week 8
March 11, 13

Sir Orfeo,
Octavian



The Matter of Rome

myth in history

history in myth

Week 9
March 18, 20

Sayers' translation of
The Song of Roland



Charlemagne: real or imaginary?

religious slander in medieval/renaissance epic

Week 10
March 25, 27

Reynolds' translation of Ariosto,
Orlando Furioso
Cantos 1-9

Friday March 28
11:59 PM
:
Argument 2
(
readings & lectures
weeks 6-10)


Italian versions of the Matter of France

 

Ariosto’s monstrous patrons

 

The beginning is not really the beginning.

Week 11
April 1, 3
Ariosto, Orlando Furioso
Cantos 10-18


traitors and heroes in the court of Charlemagne

 

“I am no man!” The female heroes of Ariosto’s epic

Week 12
April 8, 10
Ariosto, Orlando Furioso
Cantos 19-27
Thursday April 10: 
Quiz 3 

(readings: weeks
8-12)


“I tell thee, love’s but a madness...”

Ariosto: romantic or anti-romantic?


Week 13
April 15, 17
Ariosto, Orlando Furioso
Cantos 28-36


Stealing from the best: the sources of Ariosto

The bad guys of the epic: how bad are they, really?

 

Prequels and sequels: other writers of Italian epic

Week 14
April 22, 24

Ariosto, Orlando Furioso
Cantos 37-45
Thursday April 24: 
Quiz 4
(lectures & readings weeks 13-14)


Moon shots: space travel in ancient and Renaissance literature


Homer, Ariosto, and St. John the Evangelist: just a trio of hacks?

 

The physical cosmos of Ariosto’s epic

 

The moral cosmos of Ariosto’s epic


The end is not really the end.

Finals Week
April 28-May 2
-----
Final Project due
Tuesday April 29 

(11:59 PM)
 

Use and cite the required texts;
don't do "research"
(i.e. aimlessly Google stuff).


 
 
Return to JMP syllabi
Go to BGSU Main Page